Refine Search
Sort by
$650,000
5 Beds 4 Baths 1140090 MLS
The icon of Bethany. What began as the former telephone exchange building, which was built in 1940, the sellers built "The Cove" in 1980, using lumber and building materials, including stain glass, from a church in Illinois that was built in 1873, as well as flooring from the old Earl Harris house, a landmark residence, and many other historic buildings across the city. This house was built with an artist's hands, incorporating other master craftsmen. Miller Gerardy was the architect. Sitting on 3 city lots, this home is a sight to see. As you enter the home, you will notice the architectural craftsmanship of the ceilings and an inviting lanai with a waterfall. You will see the spiral staircase that leads to a bedroom loft with its own bathroom and closet. Notice the custom 2-way gas fireplace is present in the front room and in the primary suite. The kitchen is large with a desk area and room for a table. The formal dining area can accommodate a large dining table for those big family holiday dinners. With 5 bedrooms and at least 3 different living areas, there is plenty of room to spread out in this sprawling home. There is even a room with a kitchenette and bathroom with its own door to the outside. Being across the street from the college, this room would be ideal for a college student. Attached to the home is the beautiful Repunzel-esque tower that is definitely eye-catching. Ground level of the tower is a workshop with a vacuum system so you can get rid of the saw dust and always have a clean space for working. The upper level is perfect for a green house. Or for the avid reader, it would make a perfect library/reading nook or meditation room. Windmill works and pumps potable water! Would make an amazing and much needed B&B for the college and community or a chance for you to own and privately reside in a piece of Bethany history! You have to come see it to believe it! Appraisal proves 5000 sqft. Brand new roof, newer HVAC system.

6601 NW 42nd Street, Bethany

$159,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 1134558 MLS
Welcome to your charming & updated cottage style home in Bethany school district! Featuring 3 beds, 1 1/2 baths & an oversized 1 car attached garage, this corner lot home is ready for you to move right in! Newer luxury wood style flooring extends throughout the home including bedrooms! Kitchen & bathrooms feature granite countertops, crisp white wooden cabinetry & updated faucets. Seller offering a home warranty for the new buyer! Built-in storage abounds in the home including hall linen storage, corner built-ins in the dining room along with a wall of built-ins in the master bedroom (in addition to a spacious closet!) The extended length garage is attached to the home and also provides additional storage. Nearly half of the wood privacy fence is brand new including the gate. A large partially shaded yard offers a multitude of options for the space!

4301 N Wheeler Avenue, Bethany

$135,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 1079411 MLS
This charming house for sale in Bethany is situated on a spacious corner lot, offering a sense of privacy and a well-desired location. The property has undergone a complete transformation with recent renovations, providing a contemporary and updated living space. With two generously sized bedrooms and a well-appointed bathroom, this home offers comfortable living for a small family or young professionals seeking a cozy retreat. The interior boasts a modern design, featuring an open concept floor plan with ample natural light flowing through large windows, creating a bright and inviting atmosphere.The kitchen has been fully remodeled, showcasing stylish cabinetry, quartz countertops, and stainless steel appliances. It provides a perfect space for culinary enthusiasts and makes entertaining a breeze.The house also includes a spacious living room that serves as the heart of the home, providing a comfortable space to relax, unwind, and entertain guests.Overall, this beautifully remodeled and thoughtfully updated house in Bethany presents a fantastic opportunity for buyers looking for a move-in ready home. Its combination of stylish interiors, a corner lot, and convenient location make it undoubtedly worth considering for those seeking comfortable living in a sought-after community.

4615 N Hammond Avenue, Bethany

$340,000
4 Beds 12 Baths 1101124 MLS
Discover your dream home nestled in the highly sought after award winning Bethany School District renowned for its exceptional schools and welcoming neighbors where everyone is family!! Move-in ready home on 2 beautifully landscaped lots with 4 bedrooms, 2 1/2 baths and an over-sized 2 car garage with in-ground storm shelter. Home has real wood flooring and has been updated with newer windows, new dishwasher, new exterior paint, etc. HUGE master bedroom downstairs with en suite bath and THREE closets! 3 bedrooms and 1 bathroom upstairs. This charming residence boasts a tranquil backyard oasis, perfect for relaxation, gardening and outdoor gatherings. Two outbuildings that will remain with the property; one with electric. Home has water well for irrigation. Cedar and metal covered patio. Separate fenced backyard area already set up for your garden with many raised planters and set up with drip irrigation. Plenty of room for a pool!

4403 N Hammond Avenue, Bethany

$199,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 1079530 MLS
Back on the market at NO FAULT of the Seller! Buyer did everything they could to close the sale on this beauty, but their financing ultimately fell through. Their loss is your gain! Motivated Seller made a HUGE price drop! Act Now! Completely remodeled in BETHANY Schools! This charming home was remodeled from the studs out in 2019. Everything has been redone from the roof, HVAC, even all new plumbing all the way to the main sewer line. Beautiful open concept design with spacious living area, an open kitchen with a large island, gas stove, a large farmhouse style sink, and beautiful vinyl floors all throughout the home! The floor plan is just what you have been looking for with two good size bedrooms and a full bath towards the front of the home and a large master bedroom in the back of the home. The master bedroom features a full bath, high ceilings, and a large walk in closet. Backyard is spacious with a nice size deck attached to the backdoor. Seller has left part of the fence open to allow for parking. This well priced, beautiful home won't last long! Schedule your showing today!

4810 N Beaver Avenue, Bethany

$420,000
4 Beds 12 Baths 1105273 MLS
Rare opportunity to live in Bethany Schools on one of the most sought out streets with ability to acquire a rental property at the same time! Both on separate lots but can be purchased together. This beautifully remodeled main home with a recently added wing is situated in the heart of Bethany. This home has had many upgrades, improvements and added square footage in the past three years including a second living space, a large primary bedroom with ensuite, a walk-in pantry with a multitude of storage, a spacious laundry room, and full guttering added just a year ago. An expanded front porch was added as well as a huge back deck. This home still has light touches of the original charm, only better and more efficient. Solar was added a year ago so there's typically NO electric bill!! The split floorplan allows for three bedrooms on one side and primary suite on the other. The sunny kitchen includes an adorable breakfast nook with window view to the street. Nearly every square inch of this home has been updated, repainted, remodeled or added in the past three years, including the roof! The home now has great flow and practical spaces. This is not cookie-cutter living. Embrace the walk-ability of this community with sidewalks, a school crossing guard and friendly neighborhood gatherings. The street is even blocked off at Halloween for safety in trick-or-treating where many of the neighbors participate and others just enjoy the view from their front porches. At Christmastime, walk to downtown Bethany to celebrate the season with the food trucks & craft tables then stroll in and out of the stores where the shopkeepers open their doors with hot chocolate, candy canes and a visit with Santa. Come and build a lifestyle here. It's waiting for you! Listing Agent is related to seller. Rental property next door is at 4510 N College, MLS#1105241

4600 N College Avenue, Bethany

$450,000
6 Beds 4 Baths 1122984 MLS
***Highly rated BETHANY PUBLIC SCHOOLS*** Just in time for a new school year! You’d be 4 blocks from the school, with many neighborhood students making the walk. It makes your life so easy!! No waiting in a pickup line ever again! This home has space for everyone. It is perfect for a multi-generation setup with additional living and kitchen space! There is an option to use as a duplex. However, the home is zoned residential/single family. To use as duplex, you’d need to rezone. But it would be a money maker! The home was newly built in 2021 with all the upgrades! Wood floors throughout. Sprinkler system, landscaping, move in ready! 6 bedrooms! 4 baths! 2 full kitchens! Bonus room. Iron fenced yard. Don’t forget - your kids can walk to school!!

4300 N Donald Avenue, Bethany

$100,000
1 Beds 1 Baths 1105241 MLS
RARE OPPORTUNITY!!! Adorable tiny home to live in or investment as Air bnb in the heart of Bethany! It's literally right behind Bethany Nazarene College, along Route 66 and is lovingly called the Sugar Shack. It's ideal for renting to a college student or air bnb for your best return. Being in the perfect location, just off Route 66, it has been consistently rented as air bnb bringing in about $1500/mo. The roof was installed in 2020 with gutters added and the interior was all remodeled and updated the same year. HVAC was newly installed in 2022. This rare find is going to be offered to the purchaser of the main home next door (4600 N College, MLS#1105273) before selling to an independent buyer. It is on a separate lot with separate utilities. Listing agent is related to seller.

4510 N College Avenue, Bethany

$229,900
2 Beds 1 Baths 1105042 MLS
Welcome to your dream home in the coveted Bethany school district, where charm meets modern convenience. This beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom residence spans 1,415 square feet and is designed to impress. The moment you step inside, you'll be greeted by spacious rooms that flow seamlessly. The living area boasts elegant wood floors, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The kitchen is a culinary enthusiast's delight, a double oven, a gas range, and granite countertops. The bedrooms are generously sized. The primary bedroom includes a walk-in closet. Practicality meets convenience with a large utility, laundry, and storage area. Situated on a desirable corner lot, this property offers a detached 2-car garage, providing secure parking and extra storage. The fenced yard is a perfect place to play safely, while the covered patio is an ideal spot for outdoor gatherings or simply enjoying a peaceful evening. A storm shelter adds an extra layer of security, ensuring you're prepared for any weather. This home's updates and amenities make it a standout choice in the Bethany area. Enjoy the benefits of a vibrant community with top-rated schools. Make this Bethany gem yours and start creating lasting memories.

5001 N Mueller Avenue, Bethany

$187,500
3 Beds 2 Baths 1122183 MLS
The updated 4800 Willow Ave has 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 gorgeous baths with a 6yr old roof and HVAC. Energy Star Windows. Now to the Pretties: Newer lighting, and gorgeous waterproof vinyl wood plank floors! This very open floor plan has pretty kitchen cabs with an island, recessed lighting plus a chandelier and Stainless steel appliances. Ceiling fans in the living and all bedrooms as well as new carpet. Formal dining with second chandelier! Beautiful shower features. Master has 6ft shower with tumbled marble seat and dual shower heads! Willow has a spacious Laundry room to make life easier. Eat peaches from your own peach tree! All in the Highly Sought After Bethany School District. You don't want to miss this beauty!

4800 N Willow Avenue, Bethany

$130,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 1113969 MLS
Adorable home in the exclusive Bethany School District! Charming curb appeal with a cozy front porch. This home has so much potential! Tons of updates include, Central Heat & Air, Updated Flooring, and a Remodeled Bathroom & Kitchen! The spacious living room is adorned with beautiful flooring and light and bright windows! The kitchen has been updated yet tastefully preserved! Both bedrooms are well appointed and offer easy access to the full bathroom. The bathroom is perfectly equipped with a shower and tub combo. Immaculate inside! Large backyard with awesome deck! This home is perfect for the investor that wants to to enhance this gorgeous property. The detached garage offers 3 bays for storage or parking. Upstairs garage boasts potential living quarters or studio workspace in need of TLC. See the list of updates.

4503 N Peniel Avenue, Bethany

$210,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 1119513 MLS
This 3bd/2ba ranch is a fabulous find on an oversized corner lot just blocks from Southern Nazarene University and highly sought after Bethany Elementary, Middle & High Schools. The welcoming front entry opens into a large open living space with a woodburning fireplace. Perfect for gatherings, the living room is open to both the dining room and kitchen. A spacious covered patio is accessed thru a dining room while the bedrooms are located off a central hall past the kitchen. The primary bedroom boasts an updated ensuite as well as a private covered porch and convenient laundry closet. Two secondary bedrooms are served by a full hall bath. A spacious carport provides valuable shade and shelter for at least 2 vehicles and a partial basement provides peace of mind during severe weather events. At nearly 13,000 square feet, this lot holds endless possibilities for homeowners and investors alike, come see it today!

4301 N Redmond Avenue, Bethany

$475,000
4 Beds 12 Baths 1071524 MLS
Unmatched Opportunity in the Bethany Public School District. Completely remodeled with high end finishes in 2010 such as, solid hardwood flooring, thick granite used in kitchen, oversized kitchen island, walk-in pantry, 48 inch, dual fuel Kitchenaid range, recessed lighting, Larson heavy duty glass storm doors, wired for generator hookup... and the list goes on... 35,000 gallon, gunite saltwater pool with ionization system for purification, approx 8 feet at the deep end with a tanning shelf and stamped concrete surround, mature Pecan trees, 40 year, high-impact shingle roof (2021) and large wood-burning fireplace with gas connection available. All of this located on a corner lot in one of the most desirable streets in the Bethany School District. See your Realtor for a comprehensive list of upgrades and improvements. Buyer to verify all details.

4311 N Peniel Avenue, Bethany

Copyright © 2026 MLSOK, Inc. This information is believed to be accurate but is not guaranteed. Subject to verification by all parties. The listing information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This data is copyrighted and may not be transmitted, retransmitted, copied, framed, repurposed, or altered in any way for any other site, individual and/or purpose without the express written permission of MLSOK, Inc. Information last updated on .